Discussion about this post

User's avatar
J Thompson's avatar

Enjoyed, thank you!

"It wasn't racial animus that earned her only 5% black approval in the 2020 Democratic primary" is exactly right. Black voters rejected her because of specific choices she made—fighting to keep people in prison, her office's mishandling of wrongful convictions, truancy prosecutions that punished poor Black families, and a broader record that reform advocates saw as harmful.

When you build a career making decisions that materially hurt Black communities, then lose and say "America wasn't ready for a Black woman," it's delusional.

The 2020 primary already told the story. Black Democratic voters, highly engaged and informed, looked at her record and said "no thanks." That wasn't racism- it was an informed electorate.

So when she lost again in 2024, the real question isn't "was America ready for a Black woman?" It's "why would Black voters rally behind someone whose record worked against them?"

Obama built trust. Harris built a prosecution record.

And here's the killer: For all Trump's flaws—and they are scores—he signed the First Step Act in 2018, delivering actual criminal justice reform that reduced mandatory minimums and expanded early release programs.

The "law and order" candidate who called for the death penalty for the Central Park Five did more for criminal justice reform, and thus largely the black community, than the Black woman prosecutor.

When Trump can credibly claim he helped reduce mass incarceration while Harris spent her career enabling it, her "America wasn't ready" excuse is a clear confession that she still doesn't understand why she lost.

Expand full comment

No posts